Should I buy methanol from an agent or direct from the importer?

If you buy methanol by the tanker load, buy direct from the importer that brings it in through its own pier and storage, and pick up at its depot. An agent adds a layer: a margin, another pair of hands on your order, and one more person who knows your volumes. Small, occasional buyers may still need one.

A client called me this week with a strange question: did I know a certain agent?

I didn’t. So I called him back to find out what it was about. He buys methanol from me by the tanker load, direct, no middleman. Some weeks back, an agent had been trying to win his business. This week the same agent came back to him already knowing he had just bought from me.

My client wanted to know how a stranger knew his business. Fair question.

How an agent can know your order

Not from the terminal. Order details stay between the buyer and the importer. What nobody controls is what people see in the open.

A terminal loading area is a busy place. Tankers from many dealers and end users queue at the same gate. Most trucks carry a livery or a company name painted on the door and the tank. Anyone standing nearby can read which company’s truck is loading, and at which terminal.

In my experience, that’s where most of this comes from. Some dealers’ truck drivers double as their eyes on the ground. They note which trucks are loading, whose name is on them, and how often they come, and they report it back to their office. From there, a sales call to you is easy.

Nobody leaked the order. The truck announced it.

What an agent actually offers

Agents, traders and resellers are part of this trade. Most buyers start with one. I don’t say avoid them all. I say know what you’re paying for.

An agent usually offers one of these:

  • A lower price on one load. Often a one-off, from stock someone needs to move, or a gap between two cargoes. In the trade we call it an opportunity. On the street it’s called fly-by-night.
  • Convenience. One call, they handle the rest.
  • Small quantities. Drums or a part load when the importer only sells by the tanker.
  • Credit terms the importer won’t give a new buyer.

What you give up is harder to see:

  • Their margin. It’s inside the price whether you see it or not.
  • Continuity. The cheap load doesn’t come with next month’s load. When supply gets tight, the importer serves its direct accounts first.
  • Traceability. Who loaded it, from which tank, under whose certificate of analysis? The more hands, the harder that answer gets.
  • Privacy. Every extra hand on your order is one more person who knows what you buy and when.

On one load, the saving can look real. On a year of tanker loads, it isn’t small money either way. It’s a substantial amount, and you want to know who you’re actually buying from.

When buying direct makes sense

Volume, use and situation decide this, not loyalty.

Buy direct if you take methanol in bulk, on a regular schedule, for a process that can’t stop: biodiesel, formaldehyde and resin plants, solvent blending, fuel use. That’s the buyer an importer wants to plan stock for.

An agent or reseller can still make sense if you buy a few drums at a time, irregularly, or need a mixed order of several chemicals in one delivery.

Most plants start with the second and grow into the first. When you outgrow the agent, move. Shape your buying the way a proper distribution channel works: importer, storage, your plant.

How to tell an importer from a trader

Ask a few direct questions. A real importer answers them without hesitating:

  1. Where does the product land? An importer names its pier and its terminal or depot: a port and a place, such as a terminal in Batangas, not just a warehouse address.
  2. Can I pick up at your depot? If they can’t tell you where the tank is, they don’t own one.
  3. Whose certificate of analysis is this? It should come from the tank or lot you are buying, not a generic sheet.
  4. Whose name is on the delivery receipt? It should be the company you are paying.
  5. Can I visit? An importer with a terminal can arrange it.

Pick up from the depot, quietly

If you’re big enough to buy direct, pick up at the importer’s depot with your own trucks or a hauler you contract. You set the schedule, you see the loading, and you know whose hands the product passes through.

If you’d rather other sellers not know your buying pattern, a plain truck helps. A tanker with your company name on the door tells everyone at the gate who’s buying. Brief your drivers and your hauler not to discuss loads with other drivers, and put confidentiality in your hauling agreement.

Buying methanol for your plant?

Tell me your use, your monthly volume and how you take delivery now. I’ll tell you honestly whether you’re at the point where buying direct makes sense, and what to ask for.

Chemicals in this answer

Still not sure?Ask Mark