Chlorine tablets or granules: which is better for my pool?
It depends on your pool and on who runs it. Tablets suit pools with a floater or feeder, because they dissolve slowly and dose steadily with little labor. Granules suit attendants who dose by hand and need to correct fast, such as after a busy weekend. My pick is tablets: they save time, and the system just works.
Pool buyers ask me this one more than almost anything else: tablets or granules? There’s no single right answer. TCCA 90 tablets and TCCA 90 granules are the same chemistry, trichloroisocyanuric acid, also sold as TICA. Neo-Chlor 90 comes both ways. What changes is how the chlorine gets into the water, and that depends on three things.
It depends on the pool, the person and the swimmers
The equipment. Some pools have a tablet feeder or an inline chlorinator. Others have nothing, and dosing means a scoop and a bucket. If there’s no feeder, tablets need at least a floater.
The person who runs it. Some pool attendants like to dose by hand, see the water and adjust. Others have a long list of jobs and want the chlorine to look after itself.
The swimmers. A hotel or condo pool has low days and high days. Five swimmers on a Tuesday and eighty on a Sunday need different amounts of chlorine. How you handle that swing matters more than the form you buy.
Why tablets: steady dosing, less labor
A tablet dissolves slowly. In a feeder or floater it releases chlorine over days, so the level stays even instead of spiking after each dose and dropping before the next.
Some buyers think tablets cost more. Per kilo of chlorine, the product is the same TCCA. The saving comes from how it’s used:
- Less labor. Load the feeder, check it, top it up. No daily scooping.
- Fewer swings. Steady chlorine means fewer cloudy days and less correcting.
- Less waste. Hand dosing tends to overshoot, then undershoot. A well-set feeder doesn’t.
How long a load lasts depends on the feeder setting, water flow, temperature and the swimmer load, so set it for your pool and adjust.
Why granules: fast, flexible, hands-on
Granules dissolve much faster than tablets. They suit:
- Pools with no feeder and an attendant who doses by hand.
- Quick corrections, such as after a crowded weekend or heavy rain.
- Small or irregular pools, where a feeder isn’t worth installing.
The trade-off is labor and consistency. Someone has to dose every day, and the chlorine level rises and falls between doses. Follow the label on how to add granules. Don’t let them sit undissolved on the pool floor, because concentrated TCCA can stain or bleach the surface.
Two things to watch with either form
Cyanuric acid builds up. TCCA is stabilized chlorine: a little more than half of its weight ends up in the pool as cyanuric acid (CYA). CYA shields chlorine from the sun, which helps in Philippine heat. But it never leaves the water except by draining or dilution, and too much makes the chlorine sluggish. Tablets and granules add CYA at the same rate per kilo, so test for it every month either way. When it climbs too high, replace part of the water or switch to an unstabilized chlorine such as calcium hypochlorite for a while.
Never mix TCCA with calcium hypochlorite. Not in the same feeder, scoop, bucket or shelf. The two can react with heat and toxic gas, and a sealed feeder can build pressure until the lid blows off. If a feeder has ever held another chlorine, clean it out completely before loading TCCA. And never put tablets or granules straight into the skimmer.
My pick
If you ask me, I’d choose tablets. They’re easier to use, save time and need less labor. Once the feeder is set, the system just works. Granules earn their place when there’s no feeder, or as a quick fix on busy days. You don’t have to pick only one: tablets can carry the daily base, with granules on hand for the weekend spike.
Not sure which fits your pool?
Tell me your pool size, whether you have a feeder or floater, who doses it, and how busy it gets on weekends. I’ll tell you which form fits and what’s available now.